The Best Auto Insurance Companies For 2018

Independent car insurance site Clearsurance recently ranked the best car insurance companies. The list is based on factors such as affordability, customer service, the scope of coverage and users’ likelihood to recommend their insurance to others or renew with the company.

Surprisingly, only two national insurance companies made the cut. The others were smaller and mid-size companies.

Clearsurance sifted through more than 39,000 customer reviews that policyholders submitted on the website. Here’s their list of the top 10 insurers:

1. New Jersey Manufacturers Insurance Co. (NJM)

Overall score: 4.7 out of 5


Overall score: 4.69

3. Amica Mutual Insurance Company

Overall score: 4.51

4. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company

Overall score: 4.49

5. Erie Insurance Group

Overall score: 4.48

6. Auto-Owners Insurance Group

Overall score: 4.45

7. AAA

Overall score: 4.34

8. The Hartford

Overall score: 4.33

9. Geico

Overall score: 4.28

10. American Family Insurance

Overall score: 4.27

There’s Never a Fee Unless We Get Money For You

Font Resize